Star Trek/Doctor Who Assimilation2 Issue 2

Published On July 12, 2012 | By Zainab | Comics, Reviews

Star Trek TNG/ Doctor Who Assimilation2 Issue 2

Scott and David Tipton, Tony Lee, J.K. Woodward

IDW

A Star Trek/Dr Who crossover. Strictly one for the fanboys, right? But, you know, I don’t think it is. Having only watched the 2009 JJ Abrams Star Trek movie and the newer Dr Who series, I don’t think I classify as either a Trekkie or a Whovian, and I’m really enjoying this so far. I work with some huge Trek and Who fans, which is how I ended up buying it depsite being a trade waiter. Since I’ve been snared into issue buying, I thought it would be nice to do mini-reviews on these as they come out each month, although they’ll probably be more a recount of events more than anything.  For a quick recap on the first issue, may I direct you here.

Issue 2 rolls back time a little, joining the Enterprise crew a few hours prior to the Borg invasion as they make an inspection of a mining plant on a host planet. The set-up is a precarious one- the planet is mainly water with some mountain terrain through which drilling takes place, making it extremely hazardous. It doesn’t help that while the native water-resident aliens have given permission for the extraction of resources, they are not any definition of friendly- refusing to get involved even if people are in danger.  Dispatched to assess the safety of the operation, Commander Riker and Lieutenant Worf find out just how unstable and risky it is when part of the machinery collapses suddenly, flooding the area. Luckily no-one is harmed.

Upon return to the Enterprise, Captain Picard sends them to check out a new simulation on the Holodeck as a way of relaxing. The simulation is of a bar in San Francisco in 1941 and all appears to be working fine until three people enter, one of whom recognises Data as an android straightaway. The crew are surprised by the Holodeck’s level of advancement and as they engage further in conversation with the charcaters, suspecting first sentience and then malfunction, before deciding to end the exercise. But the three people and the TARDIS still remain. . . 

The powered-down Holodeck immediately reminded me of the Dreamatorium in Community- a nod to the Doctor Who spoof homage Inspector Spacetime perhaps (haven’t seen that but this is how the holodeck has looked when powered down since TNG started in the 80s – Joe, who is a Trekkie). From there, it’s a short trip for the Doctor, Amy and Rory to Captain Picard.  Even as everyone sizes one another up and the Doctor tries to work out why he has never come across these particular planets and peoples having traipsed across the whole of the universe, a distress signal is received: there has been an invasion by the joint forces of the Borg and the Cybermen.

A slower second issue this, which is to be expected as we’re given more set-up. It works nicely though and it’s good to see that the writers are focusing on building the story and resisting the temptation to simply produce fan-boy moments. The pacing is spot on and there’s no rush to careen from action scene to action scene. I’m not really a fan of painted artwork in comics -too static and stiff- but it doesn’t detract from the story here in any way. They may yet have a part to play, but so far the Ponds have felt rather redundant, whereas in a shorter space of time, the Star Trek crew have established themselves as a unit with everyone contributing equally.

Some intriguing points introduced in this issue – the Doctor finds himself knowing what a Klingon is, yet has never come across any of the species on the Enterprise, nor any of their planets. Also the precarious mining situation and Picard’s insistence on continuing seems suspect. I really like what they’re doing so far with this crossover, but to be honest it’s solid rather than spectacular. Of course the horrible by-product of this experiment is I now am starting to veer towards issue buying as perhaps not a bad thing. Which is in itself a very bad thing.

Like this Article? Share it!

About The Author

Zainab
Zainab Akhtar is a qualified librarian with a specialisation in building comics collections. She currently writes for Forbidden Planet and The Beat, and is a committee member for the British Comics Awards.'

3 Responses to Star Trek/Doctor Who Assimilation2 Issue 2

  1. badblokebob says:

    “The pacing is spot on” — Four pages spent describing engineering details we don’t need to know of a mining operation we don’t need to know about on a planet we don’t need to know about beg to differ.

  2. Zainab says:

    I don’t mind that kind of detail myself :)

    Have to admit though, I still assumed that it’s foreshadowing and the operation will play some sort of role, otherwise, as you say, it is a bit laborious introducing us to everything.

  3. Rod Morgan says:

    Hideous wish-fulfilment fanfiction for a slow-witted fanboys and girls. If rot like this had existed when Dr Who and Star Trek had begun, they would have never made it to the screens, which would have been clogged with Dixon Of Dock Green/Dragnet mash-ups. Comics at their most moribund – which is saying something.